I have to assume Keir Starmer ISN’T an idiot.
I appreciate that there are countless examples of people in high positions who are patently unsuited to their roles, but Starmer was on top of his brief as Shadow Brexit Secretary, he was formerly Director of Public Prosecutions… Surely he CAN’T be stupid?
But he does make it awfully hard to believe that.
The latest idea to bubble to the top is Digital ID Cards, something not even in the wind Wednesday, rumoured Thursday, and announced Friday. Setting aside the “is he or isn’t he a thicko” debate, I admire his willingness to announce schemes that NOBODY wants. Freezing the pensioners, playing swapsies with the French, and now this.
Digital ID Cards are absolutely essential (apparently) to crack down on illegal immigrants, by preventing them working in the UK. (We presumably have to set aside the implication that therefore he’s giving up on stopping them actually getting here in the first place.) Because employers will need to check ID before employing anybody.
I mean, yes, I guess, on the face of it, maybe, that does sound reasonable. But alas, only if you are (as suggested above) a stupid idiot. Because he would surely only announce such a scheme if he was somehow blissfully aware that we already have the National Insurance number. That is, a UNIQUE number for EVERY person, used by every employer for every employee on the PAYE system.
In the old days, I’ll accept, it would be pretty easy to fake that – we all know the format so giving your new boss a credible number would be child’s play (they don’t call me Mr AM 44 51 28 C for nothing). But for at least the past decade each time an employer runs their payroll they have to submit it electronically to HMRC.
In other words, it is now easy for HMRC to check that ALL the numbers on ALL the payrolls in ALL the UK are correct. Not just correct, it should also be easy to check that each NI numbers is only being used once. Being a UNIQUE number it would be pretty easy for an exceptions report to highlight any number linked to a worker in Dumfries AND also somebody drawing a pension in Sidmouth, or signing on in Maidstone. The optimist in me would like to think there’s ALREADY such a report (because in a sense, if nobody is actually checking anything, why are we submitting payrolls to HMRC in the first place?) but even if there isn’t, I suspect any half-decent programmer could get one knocked up in a morning.
The problem with the system, presumably, is that (shock!) sometimes employers DON’T put people through their PAYE system. Or, less illegally, maybe they use self-employed workers. Self-employed workers do of course also need an NI number for their tax returns. But at the risk of being branded a cynic, if I was working illegally, in a country I wasn’t supposed to be in, I probably WOULDN’T bother submitting a tax return.
At a time when we’re constantly being beaten around the head with the fact that there’s not enough money for repairing schools, recruiting dentists, heating pensioners, it constantly surprises me how much money apparently IS lying around for what feel increasingly like another of Homer Simpson’s “crazy schemes”. If checking up on illegal workers really is a big thing, then it’s surely cheaper & quicker to make the current NI system work properly, than to implement and enforce a whole NEW system. And if the reason is that they can’t make THAT system work, why on Earth do they expect more success with a NEW one?!
It’s almost a secondary point but the other puzzling thing is that, despite it being so vitally important, the intention is only for the Digital ID scheme to be in place by the end of this parliament. To me “I can get it done in four years” doesn’t smack of urgency – but it does slightly have the feel of, if there’s any problem with it at least it won’t be MY problem.
Hmm. Maybe he’s NOT so stupid after all.